We use cookies to ensure that our site works correctly and provides you with the best experience. If you continue using our site without changing your browser settings, we'll assume that you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use and how to manage them by reading our cookies policy. Hide

Current Issue

5th September 2019
Selected Chemistry & Industry magazine issue

Select an Issue

C&I

C&I e-books

C&I e-books

C&I apps

iOS App
Android App

Bring back the volcano

Posted 14/01/2010 by RoseS

I finally threw out the traditional chemistry set we bought my then ten-year-old nephew a couple of birthday’s ago just last week. After a couple of spectacularly unspectacular experiments to produce hydrogen by adding Mg to dilute HCl or relight a glowing splint with oxygen, it had sat for months gathering dust on a shelf at the back of the garden shed. The final nail in the coffin came on reading the article Whizz, bang, fizz… in the Christmas issue of C&I(2009, 24, 21), where one online educational toy retailer commented dismissively: ‘Chemistry sets sell to grandparents’. Perhaps it’s just a sign of the times; with so many more exciting computer games to compete against, adding a few chemicals into a test tube and watching a few bubbles emerge no longer holds the same attraction.

More worrying than the declining appeal of chemistry sets, however, is the alleged decline in practical hands on experience of chemistry in schools and universities. Already, according to University of Oxford microbiology professor Keith Gull, writing in the Evening Standard (7 January 2010), ‘the average UK undergraduate science experience has declined’, while the £2700 extra government funding for laboratory-based subjects is ‘totally inadequate’ to account for the higher costs of teaching science, he added. With the recently announced £533m cuts to UK university budgets, Gull warns that we are being drawn into an ever more Blue Peter-style ‘here’s one we did earlier’ approach to the teaching and learning of science, where lab demonstrations, group work, essays and electronic ‘virtual’ classes take the place of practical classes.

Chemistry school teachers would appear to agree, arguing that the modern obsession with health & safety is making it increasingly difficult to do ‘wow’ experiments without prescribed outcomes. While spectacular lecture demonstrations such as the phosphorus sun undoubtedly have their attractions, there’s no substitute for carrying out your own DIY experiments in the lab and learning from your successes - or more often failures.

There are plenty of ideas about experiments you might try with the kids at home, but my own personal favourite – and oft repeated with my niece and nephew especially as all the ingredients are readily available in the kitchen cupboard - is still the volcano. Simply add sodium bicarbonate to vinegar and stand back. Of course, it adds to the special effects if you have the right set: a colourful paper mache volcano. And be sure to add plenty of bicarb. Definitely not a reaction for grandparents.

Cath O’Driscoll - Deputy Editor

Add your comment

 
 

 

Comments

  • Anonymous said:
    15/10/2013 06:31

    My husband and i were happy when Albert could carry out his recraesh via the precious recommendations he got when using the blog. It's not at all simplistic to just find yourself handing out tips and tricks that most people might have been selling. So we know we've got you to thank for that. The entire explanations you made, the straightforward web site menu, the friendships you can help instill it's many superb, and it's really leading our son and us recognize that the idea is amusing, and that's exceptionally serious. Thanks for all the pieces! http://aczucaxi.com [url=http://wmlirzxm.com]wmlirzxm[/url] [link=http://nhogfzgcag.com]nhogfzgcag[/link]

  • Anonymous said:
    14/10/2013 07:04

    Thanks representing the ideas<a href="http://tlpyut.com"> matuul</a> resting on your own blog. Another thing I would like to testify is that fat reduction is not on the subject of going by a dietary fads and frustrating to lower as a great deal weight as you can in a set period of time. The mainly operational sense to spend burden is by consuming it little by insignificant and next a number of basic recommendations which can assist you to achieve the most owing to your attempt to shed stress. You may recognize and previously be subsequent countless of these tips, yet reinforcing expertise never hurts.

  • Anonymous said:
    13/10/2013 10:03

    Needed to post you one little bit of note to thank you so much again with your sunnnitg solutions you've shared at this time. It was simply particularly open-handed with people like you to give unreservedly what exactly many people could possibly have marketed as an ebook to end up making some dough on their own, primarily considering that you could have tried it in case you decided. The creative ideas likewise worked to provide a great way to realize that other individuals have a similar eagerness similar to my personal own to grasp a lot more with regards to this condition. Certainly there are thousands of more enjoyable moments in the future for those who look into your blog post.

Captcha

Archive