We use cookies to ensure that our site works correctly and provides you with the best experience. If you continue using our site without changing your browser settings, we'll assume that you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use and how to manage them by reading our cookies policy. Hide

Current Issue

19th February 2020
Selected Chemistry & Industry magazine issue

Select an Issue


C&I e-books

C&I e-books

C&I apps

iOS App
Android App

Frankenfood returns?

Posted 06/08/2013 by cgodfrey

Have we as scientists learnt nothing from the European debacle over genetically modified (GM) food? Now whether you support the introduction of GMOs or not, it was to be hoped that the lessons that were so sorely learnt by Monsanto might have influenced those who organised this week’s unveiling of the first so-called ‘test tube burger’.

Greater preparation for the launch, not just for the burger itself, might have meant that it would not have suffered the same accusations that we remember from the first discussions of GM crops, like the term Frankenfood, which has been shocked into new life itself.

After all, everyone concerned with the projects has had over 18 months to consider the launch since C&I carried a feature-length account in November 2011 of the group’s efforts to grow meat in the laboratory rather than the field. And it is not as if the project’s backer, also revealed this week as the co-founder of Google, Sergey Brin, does not know anything about the value of marketing!

After watching the frying of the ceremonial burger, it was handed to the official first tasters who themselves were virtually unknown, at least to a UK audience. Had it been impossible to find any more visible, and perhaps supportive, food experts? And watching this group of unknowns eat their portions of burger was an increasingly restive audience made up mainly of journalists all looking for a story – and as we all know the only story that makes the headlines is a scare story or one that at least hints at bad news. 

And to talk about using stem cells from a dead cow is really just asking for problems; and synthetic isn’t really the right world for something that is based on, and grown from, a natural product.

There can be no argument with the basic premise behind the project that aims to meet the demands for meat eating from an ever-increasing global population. And thanks to the various environmental groups we all now know the quantities of land, water, feed etc that are needed to fulfil our demand for meat – humans are designed as omnivores after all; just look at our teeth!

This is a first tentative step in this very long project – already six years old – to help meet this key societal challenge to feed the world. Whether it will ultimately be successful remains to be seen – the initial taste and texture responses from the tasters were not particularly encouraging – but to have not prepared the ground thoroughly will only make the team’s job harder.

Would I eat it? I don’t know, but then as a science fiction fan I can’t forget Edward G. Robinson’s last cinematic role with Charlton Heston in Soylent Green – at least in that story the food was made from dead humans! 

What do you think? Let’s see what you have to say below.

Neil Eisberg - Editor

Add your comment




  • Anonymous said:
    15/11/2013 06:52

    Thanks for your beneficial post. As time <a href="http://ttnnhdbf.com">pasess</a>, I have been able to understand that the actual symptoms of mesothelioma are caused by this build up connected fluid between lining in the lung and the chest cavity. The illness may start inside chest vicinity and pass on to other limbs. Other symptoms of pleural mesothelioma include fat loss, severe breathing in trouble, nausea, difficulty taking in food, and irritation of the face and neck areas. It needs to be noted that some people having the disease usually do not experience any kind of serious indications at all.

  • Anonymous said:
    14/11/2013 03:37

    I must say, as a whole lot as I enjoyed renaidg what you had to say, I couldnt assist but shed interest soon after a although. Its as should you had a wonderful grasp on the subject matter, but you forgot to incorporate your readers. Maybe you must think about this from far a lot more than 1 angle. Or perhaps you shouldnt generalise so considerably. Its greater in case you think about what other people might need to say rather of just going for a gut reaction towards the topic. Think about adjusting your own believed procedure and giving other people who may possibly read this the benefit of the doubt. http://xscdrxxcrgz.com [url=http://oxakewur.com]oxakewur[/url] [link=http://ofcffpwci.com]ofcffpwci[/link]

  • Anonymous said:
    12/11/2013 03:20

    I acquired more new <a href="http://opiwuvurdea.com">thigns</a> on this fat loss issue. One issue is a good nutrition is especially vital while dieting. A massive reduction in junk food, sugary food, fried foods, sweet foods, beef, and white-colored flour products could possibly be necessary. Holding wastes parasitic organisms, and wastes may prevent targets for losing fat. While specific drugs quickly solve the issue, the horrible side effects are usually not worth it, and so they never offer more than a short-term solution. This is a known fact that 95% of celebrity diets fail. Thanks for sharing your ideas on this web site.

  • Anonymous said:
    03/11/2013 11:47

    I wish to express my <a href="http://nlvcchstra.com">aprcipiateon</a> to this writer just for rescuing me from this scenario. Right after searching throughout the world-wide-web and getting suggestions which were not helpful, I figured my life was done. Being alive without the approaches to the problems you have solved all through your guideline is a serious case, as well as those which could have adversely affected my career if I had not come across the blog. Your good training and kindness in taking care of almost everything was valuable. I don't know what I would've done if I had not come upon such a stuff like this. I can at this moment relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for your professional and result oriented help. I won't think twice to suggest your blog to any person who should get guidelines about this situation.

  • Anonymous said:
    17/10/2013 04:26

    to 匿名 above: Yes, I believe CY becemos enemy of those real riches and controller of HK now. I also believe they now use all ways to try to push CY down.Then? Do I need to start loving CY because of the reason above? or do I need support CY no matter what in order to show I have a brain in my head? http://whekkxstf.com [url=http://baofafdbr.com]baofafdbr[/url] [link=http://kdxwxplrb.com]kdxwxplrb[/link]

  • Anonymous said:
    15/10/2013 08:12

    "又有五毛出沒" Hi brainless guyFxxk you those sanyig "又有五毛出沒" or "affected by foreign enemies". Everyone make their voice for their own benefits, who fxxking care that? What's important is "WHAT IS THE REASONS BEHIND YOUR POINT"There are quite a lot of meaningful posts here, shut up and learn from it "quietly". Shame on you!